[121]
Mr. Mendes submitted that the polling process is governed by these Rules. It
begins, he said, with an application by a voter for a ballot and ends with the
depositing of the ballot in the ballot box. He insisted that consistent with the right
to vote under section 40 of the Constitution, Rule 40 should be interpreted as
meaning that a voter applies for a ballot as soon as he or she turns up at the
polling station and gets in line to vote. In that event, he suggested, the voter
becomes entitled to have a ballot delivered to him or her on arrival at the polling
station. It should not be held against the voter, said Mr. Mendes, if upon arrival
there are other persons in line equally entitled to be provided with a ballot ahead of
him or her. The voter’s entitlement to be provided with the ballot should not be
extinguished because 6:00pm arrives before he or she reaches the head of the
line. Furthermore, argued Mr. Mendes, where there are persons in line at 6:00pm,
Rules 29 and 34 should be interpreted as empowering the presiding officer to
invite those already in line to enter the polling station in order that he may carry out
his statutory duty to deliver the ballots to them.
[122]
In my view, acceptance of the foregoing submission presents an extraordinarily
strained construction on Rule 1(7) as well as of the language of Rules 29, 34 and
40 of the Election Rules.
[123]
However, I think that the learned trial judge was correct when she held that Rule
1(7) should be afforded a generous interpretation which gives meaning to the right
vote because of its constitutional pedigree. In my view, however, that is as far as
Bruno is helpful to the interpretation of Rule 1(7) because the relevant statute that
was considered in Bruno was different from the formulation in Rule 1(7).
Whereas the Bruno statute required ‘polling places’ to be closed by the stipulated
time, Rule 1(7) stipulates that ‘polling’, which is a process, should take place
between 6:00am and 6:00pm.
[124]
The use of the word ‘polling’ rather than ‘voting’ is significant, in my view. While
52
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents