[137]
The trial judge continued as follows:83
“[274] On the other hand, the Court is not of the view that it should merely
compare the turnout in the previous election, that is, 2004 and 2009
election in order to determine whether there was substantial compliance.
[275] However, having reviewed the evidence and taking into
consideration the totality of circumstances, there is no doubt that in spite
of the breach of the election law, the election was nevertheless conducted
substantially in accordance with the law as to the election.”
[138]
It is apparent that the central question upon which the learned trial judge focused
was whether there was a real election, which did not amount to a sham election or
a travesty of an election by ballot. In that context she considered whether a
substantial proportion of qualified voters were disenfranchised.
Submissions on behalf of the appellants
[139]
Mr. Mendes and Mr. Martineau agreed that a relevant factor in determining
whether there was substantial compliance is the actual turnout of voters. They
insisted that it would be absurd to invalidate an election where, for example, the
polling booths were open for only 2 out of the required 12 hours, if during that time
an overwhelming majority of the registered voters turned out and voted despite the
drastically reduced hours. In such a case, submitted counsel, the electorate would
have expressed its will and there would be no basis in common sense to declare
the elections void. Counsel relied on the following statement by Redhead J in
Halstead v Simon:84
In determining whether or not there is substantial compliance with
the law or rule as to opening and closing of the poll, one is not or
should not be confined solely to the number of polling hours which
was lost but with what was achieved, that is the number of votes
which was cast during polling hours.”
[140]
On the foregoing basis, counsel noted the observation by Redhead J85 that even
At paragraphs 274 and 275.
At pages 233-234.
85 At page 232.
83
84
60
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents