substantially in accordance with election law. Counsel insisted that these were
sufficient grounds on which to invalidate the elections on the ground of substantial
non-compliance.104
[155]
As I understand it, the complaint is that the judge should have determined the
question of substantial compliance not only from the perspective of each separate
breach but considering the conduct of the elections as a whole. Thus Mr. Guthrie
and Mr. Astaphan submitted that the judge should have determined, on the totally
of the circumstances, that the elections were conducted so badly that they were
not substantially in accordance with the law as to elections.
[156]
The trial judge found that the late opening of the polls breached Rule 1(7). She
also found that the use of the ‘photo lists’ breached electoral law. She held,
however, that this did not in and of itself mean that the conduct of the elections
was not substantially in accordance with the law as to elections. She found that
late voting did not breach electoral law so that the question whether the elections
were conducted substantially in accordance with electoral law did not arise on this
ground.
[157]
I have agreed that the trial judge correctly found that the late opening of the polls
breached Rule 1(7) and that the use of the photo-lists breached electoral law.
There were no other findings of breach of electoral law. I also found that the judge
was correct when she held that the late voting, done as she found by persons who
were in the lines before the statutory closing time, did not breach electoral law. It
seems to me, as learned counsel for the respondents seemed to concede, that the
use of the photo-lists was not serious. Their use however occasioned the delay in
the opening of the polls. Can it be said that these circumstances in the conduct of
the elections occasioned substantial non-compliance with electoral law?
104
See paragraphs 5(vi) and 5(vii) of the grounds of appeal contained in each counter-notice.
68
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents