[245] The Court is cognizant of the margin of victory between the
Petitioner and the First Respondent and the indeterminate number of
persons who were unable to vote, coupled with the number of hours of
polling lost. Taking into consideration the totality of the circumstances, the
Court is unable to say that the result was definitely affected by the breach.
Equally, based on the preponderance of the evidence, the Court cannot
find that that the result was not affected by the breach. In short, therefore,
everything turns on the test to be adopted. In my respectful opinion, in
circumstances where there is no clear evidence one way or the other
relating to the effect of the breach on the result, the correct approach is
that stated in Morgan v Simpson; followed in Considine v Didrichsen
supra; and applied in Halstead v Simon supra. Can the Court say that
the results were not affected by the breach? I cannot so say. Accordingly,
the Court accedes to the Petitioner’s request to void the elections and
declares that Ms. Jacqui-Quinn Leandro was not duly elected.”
[162]
The judge reasoned as follows in the Fernandez/Maginley case:106
“[397] The Court must now go on to consider the final issue, namely: did
the breach affect the result? In determining this issue, the Court pays
regard to the fact that some persons were unable to vote as a
consequence of the late polling. While there is no doubt that some of the
persons who went to exercise their franchise at 6 a.m. were unable to do
so as result of the late opening of the poll, there is equally clear evidence
that an indeterminate number of persons who attempted to vote at 6 am
were unable to do so.
[398] The Court reiterates that it finds very instructive the principles
enunciated in Morgan v Simpson. Insofar however, as the Court is
unable to say how many persons were indeed unable to vote as a
consequence of the breach of the election law and taking into
consideration that the margin of victory is 106 votes, the Court is of the
respectful view that the principle of law stated in Morgan v Simpson as
applied in Edgell v Glover supra is applicable. These principles were
subsequently approved an applied in Considine v Didrichsen supra.
The Court can do no more than apply those principles. The sum total of
all of this is that the Court is unable to say that the breach did not affect
the result. Accordingly, the Court has to declare the election void. Also,
in this regard, see the judgment of Redhead J in Halstead v Simon
supra.
[399] Accordingly, based on the preponderance of evidence, the Court
holds that insofar as it is unable to conclude that the breach of the
Election Law did not affect the result, the election of Mr. Maginley is
invalid. The Court has no alternative but to grant the declaration sought.”
106
At paragraphs 397-399 of the judgment.
72
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents