thereby applied a wrong principle on her interpretation of section 32(4). They also
insist that she wrongly assessed the facts which the evidence disclosed.
Interpreting section 32(4)
[165]
The interpretation of section 32(4) of the Representation of the People Act is not
free from difficulty. For one thing, the provision is formulated in the negative.
Secondly, it appears to be conjunctive on its face. At first blush, this seems to
invite an interpretation that a court must determine that the 2 main requirements in
the sub-section are satisfied before a court declares an election invalid. The
wording of the sub-section suggests that a court can only nullify an election for
breach if the court determines that the election was not conducted substantially in
accordance with election law and the breach affected the result. In the words of
Mr. Mendes, once it appears to the court that the election was conducted
substantially in accordance with the law as to elections and that the breach did not
affect the result of the election; the Court is prohibited from declaring the election
to be invalid.
[166]
However, the authorities show that the sub-section has received a disjunctive
interpretation on good principle. Accordingly, in Morgan v Simpson, the English
Court of Appeal held that on a proper construction of section 37(1) of the Act of
1949 (which is in pari materia to section 32(4) of the Antigua Act) a breach of
elections rules which affected the result was by itself enough to compel the court
to declare the election void. Lord Denning stated:108
“That section is expressed in the negative. It says when an election is not
to be declared invalid. The question of law in this case is whether it should
be transformed into the positive so as to show when an election is to be
declared invalid. So that it would run:
"A local government election shall be declared invalid (by reason of
any act or omission of the returning officer or any other person in
breach of his official duty in connection with the election or otherwise
of the local election rules) if it appears to the tribunal having
108
At page 725.
74
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents