In Edgell v Glover, Glover was declared the winner over Edgell by one vote. In
the course of the count, Edgell saw a ballot paper with a vote for Glover being
counted by an assistant. Writing on the ballot suggested that the voter had not
completed a Declaration of Identity as required by the rules. There would have
been a tie had this vote not been counted. Notwithstanding that the election was
conducted substantially in accordance with elections law, it was invalidated
because the error affected the result.
[168]
Mr. Mendes submitted that the case law has thrown up 4 propositions on the
interpretation of section 32(4) of the Representation of the People Act that guide
decisions on this or similar provisions. He adumbrated them as follows:
i)
An election must be declared to be invalid where it appears that the
election was not conducted substantially in accordance with the law as to
elections, whether or not the breach affected the result;
ii)
An election must be declared to be invalid where the breach affected the
result, whether or not the election was conducted substantially in
accordance with the law as to elections;
iii)
Where an election is conducted substantially in accordance with election
law, it can only be invalidated if the breach affected the result;
iv)
An election must be invalidated where it does not appear that the breach
did not affect the result, even though the election was conducted
substantially in accordance with the law as to elections.
[169]
I agree that the foregoing statements from Morgan v Simpson and from Edgell v
Glover are eminent authority for the first 2 propositions. A number of other cases
have followed and applied these propositions.
These include Fitzpatrick v
Hodge111 and Miller v Dobson.112
[170]
111
112
There is support for the third proposition in Morgan v Simpson. Lord Denning
(1995) S.L.T. (Sh Ct) 118.
(1995) S.L.T. (Sh Ct) 114.
76
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents