[183]
Mr. Mendes sought to impeach the judge’s finding on the facts as they relate to the
issue whether the results were affected. There is great force in his submission
that the percentage turnout in an election can be an indication as to whether a late
opening has resulted in voters being prevented from voting. He sought to draw
parallels between the percentage turnout in each contested constituency and
other constituencies where there were apparently no allegations that polling
stations opened late. Accordingly, he pointed out that in St John’s Rural West the
voter turnout of 80.48% was greater than that in St. John’s City East (80.05%), St.
John’s City South (79.56%), St. John’s Rural South (76.36%), St. John’s Rural
East (80.18%), St. Mary’s North (77.84%), All Saints East (79.87%) and All Saints
West (79.27%). There were no complaints of late opening of the polls in these
constituencies. Mr. Mendes also pointed out that in St George and St John’s
Rural North, the voter turnout of 79.02% and 79.03% respectively was greater
than that in St. John’s Rural South (76.36%) and St. Mary’s North (77.84%), where
the polls opened on time. Such evidence, he contended, strongly suggests that
the late start had no effect at all on voter turnout.
[184]
While I agree that the large voter turnout must be factored into a determination as
to whether a breach of election law affected the result, I could not arrive at a
conclusion from these numbers only. That would be speculative. Mr. Mendes
appreciated, as his further submissions show that there are other important
determinative factors which must be taken into account.
They include the
percentages of registered voters who did not vote and the margins of declared
victory, among others. Thus Mr. Mendes asked us to note, for example, that the
average percentage reduction in voter turnout in the general election was 10.56%.
He stated that although there may be a plethora of reasons to explain the fall in
voter turnout in each constituency, we might assume that if the reduction in the
contested constituencies was more than the average reduction in all
constituencies taken together, the difference might be attributable to the late
opening. He noted that in the St John’s Rural North and St George constituencies
82
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents