the percentage decreases were greater than the national average. In St John’s
Rural North the decrease was 12.07% while in St George it was 13.24%, which is
1.51% and 2.68%, respectively, above the average.
[185]
Mr. Mendes and Mr. Martineau submitted that the trial judge should have
dismissed the petitions because the petitioners provided little evidence to prove
that the results in the contested constituencies were affected by breach of
electoral law. They insisted that the petitioners provided only a few persons who
gave evidence that they personally did not vote because of the late start. Counsel
contended that apart from Latoya Joesph, there was no evidence of other persons
leaving the lines and not returning to vote. The evidence given of persons saying
that they were leaving and would not be returning is hearsay and accordingly not a
sufficient basis to determine if and, if so, how many persons did not vote because
of the late start. Counsel pointed out that in Halstead, Redhead J. found similar
evidence to be unreliable. He found that the Petitioner’s evidence that there were
large crowds of people at the polling stations and that the voters were enquiring
about ballots, and that some of them were saying that they would not come back
“is not evidence of the truth that they did not go back to vote.”121
[186]
Counsel for the appellants contended that it was also significant that only very few
credible witnesses were produced to say that they personally could not vote
because of the late start. Learned counsel insisted that if ‘droves’ of people were
disenfranchised because of the late start one would have expected them to be
volunteering to come to court to complain. The fact that so few came, said
counsel, suggests that an insignificant number of persons were prevented from
voting because of the late start. Counsel noted that this point was made by
Williams J in The Akaroa Election Petition.122
[187]
121
122
Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that since in Antigua the number of
At page 215 of the judgment in Halstead.
(1891) 10 NZLR 158, at page 166.
83
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents