proportionately, in keeping with the overall percentage of registered electors who
voted. It would also reduce the margin from which the winning and losing
candidate could claim additional votes. The judge should also have considered
the demonstrated distribution of the votes or the pattern of voting.
Assessing the available information
[193]
Counsel for all of the parties made extensive submissions on the available statistical
data. I have found the simplified breakdown provided by Mr. Mendes during the
course of the appeal hearing helpful in the manner in which it provides a basis for a
statistical assessment relating to the present issue for each contested constituency.
St George – Jonas/Quinn-Leandro petition
[194]
There were 4,414 registered voters in this constituency. The number of electors
who cast ballots was 3,488. These included 20 rejected ballots. 926 or about
20.97% of the electorate registered in the constituency did not vote. This meant
that 79.02% of the electorate voted. 92.26% voted in the 2004 general elections;
a difference of 13.24%.
The turnout in 2004 was the highest ever in this
constituency. The percentage turnout in 2009 in every constituency in Antigua
was lower than the percentage turnout in 2004. The percentage turnout in this
constituency in 2009 was greater than the percentage turnout in the St. John’s
Rural South (76.36%) and St. Mary’s North (77.84%). There was no complaint
that the polls opened late in these 2 latter constituencies. The national average
percentage turnout in 2009 was 81.02%.
The percentage turnout in this
constituency was accordingly 2% lower than the average. 926 registered voters
did not vote. Mrs. Quinn-Leandro received 1,985 votes. Mr. Jonas received
1,483. The margin of victory was 502.
[195]
If the turnout in this constituency would have been 100% but for the late start, 926
registered voters would have been disenfranchised. For this to have made a
86
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents