92.26% of the registered electors voted. From this base, the assumed number of
voters who were disenfranchised by the late opening of the polls was 585. The
margin of victory was 502 votes. Assuming that the highest poll in the history of
elections in the constituency was destined to be repeated in 2009, Mr. Jonas
would have had to receive 502 more of the 585 votes than Mrs. Quinn-Leandro in
order to equal her assumed votes. He would have required 543 or about 93% of
the assumed disenfranchised votes to 42 or 7% for Mrs. Quinn-Leandro. It is clear
that this was very highly improbable given the distribution of the votes and the fact
that Mr. Quinn-Leandro prevailed in every polling station in the constituency.
[203]
In the foregoing premises, a court could not be satisfied that the late opening of
the polls in St George affected the result or not satisfied that the result would not
have been affected by the late opening of the polls. The learned judge therefore
erred when she invalidated the election of Mrs. Quinn-Leandro on this ground. I
would therefore allow Mrs. Quinn-Leandro’s appeal and set aside the orders which
the judge made in her judgment of 31st March 2010, on Mr. Jonas’ petition.
St John’s Rural North – Fernandez/Maginley petition
[204]
The statistical information shows that there were 3,577 registered voters in this
constituency. The number of electors who cast ballots was 2827. These included
9 rejected ballots. The number of registered voters who did not vote was 750 or
about 20.97% of the electorate registered in the constituency. This meant that
79.03% of the electorate voted as opposed to 91.10% in the previous General
Election held in 2004; a difference of 12.07%. The turnout in 2004 was the
highest ever in this constituency. The percentage turnout in 2009 in every
constituency was lower than the percentage turnout in 2004. The percentage
turnout in this constituency in 2009 was greater than the percentage turnout in St.
John’s Rural South (76.36%) and St. Mary’s North (77.84%), where there was no
complaint that the polls opened late. The average percentage turnout in 2009 was
81.02%. The percentage turnout in this constituency was accordingly 1.99% lower
90
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents