[215]
Mr. Mendes informed us that 2 persons gave evidence that they turned up to vote
and left because the polls opened late. They did not return to vote. Mr. Mendes
accepted that one of them, Winston Joseph, did not vote because of the late start.
He said that the other witness, Francisco Matthias, gave conflicting reasons for not
returning to vote, although there was sufficient time for him to return later in the
afternoon to vote. He accepted that a number of other persons left the lines
before the polls opened late, but stated that the witnesses did not quantify the
number of persons who left the lines. He insisted that there is no evidence that
the number of persons who left the lines equalled or exceeded the margin of
victory of 506. Some of those who left the line returned later to vote. He further
insisted that there is no evidence that any of the persons who left the line did not
return later to vote and pointed out that the trial judge found that there was
evidence that some of the persons who left the line did not return later to vote. He
submitted that there is no evidence that the number of persons who left the lines
and did not return later to vote equalled or exceeded the margin of victory of 506.
In short, Mr. Mendes contended that Mr. Simon did not prove his case.
[216]
For my part, I note that in 2009 there were 3 polling locations in the St. John’s
Rural North constituency. Votes were cast as follows in the polling stations in
these divisions:127
Polling
Polling Station Spencer
Christian
Location
Rejected
Total
Total
Votes
Voted Listed
Armstrong Rd
A – CH
132
121
0
253
323
CL – GL
129
131
0
260
319
GO – JER
130
95
1
225
283
St. Anthony’s
Nazarene
North Road
127
Reproduced from Core Bundle Volume III of the Record of Appeal, page 136.
95
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents