decision and consequential order are set aside. It is accordingly declared that
Mrs. Quinn-Leandro was validly elected and that determination is certified to
the Speaker of the House.
(2) The appeal by the appellant, Mr. Maginley, against the judge’s decision,
contained in her judgment dated 31st March 2010, which declared that Mr.
Maginley was not validly returned as the elected Member of the Legislature of
Antigua and Barbuda for the St. John’s Rural West constituency, after
elections which were conducted on 12th March 2009, is allowed; and that
decision and consequential order are set aside. It is accordingly declared that
Mr. Maginley was validly elected and that determination is certified to the
Speaker of the House.
(3) The appeal by the appellant, Mr. Spencer, against the judge’s decision,
contained in her judgment dated 31st March 2010, which declared that Mr.
Spencer was not validly returned as the elected Member of Parliament for the
St. John’s Rural West constituency, after elections which were conducted on
12th March 2009, is allowed; and that decision and consequential order are set
aside. It is accordingly declared that Mr. Spencer was validly elected and that
determination is certified to the Speaker of the House.
(4) The counter-notices of appeal filed herein by the respondents are hereby
dismissed.
(5) The parties shall bear their own costs in the High Court as well as in these
appeal proceedings.
[230]
It would be remiss of me to sign off on this judgment without commending, with
appreciation, the work that the trial judge, Blenman J, did in these difficult cases. I
102
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents