Proposition (iv)
[173]
The legal status and meaning of proposition (iv) is not always clear. Mr. Mendes
submitted that there seems to be a contradiction between propositions (iii) and (iv).
He opined that under proposition (iii) the breach must affect the result of the
election for it to be invalidated. He submitted that under proposition (iv), however,
it appears that the election is to be invalidated, even if it does not appear that the
result was affected, as long as it does not appear that the result was not affected.
He noted that the trial judge accepted proposition (iv) as an accurate statement of
the law relying on Considine. He appeared to have doubted the soundness of
proposition (iv). He accordingly questioned the judge’s reliance on it.
[174]
I do not discern any contradiction between propositions (iii) and (iv) as Mr. Mendes
stated them. It is apparent that Mr. Mendes was of the same view when he stated
that there does not appear to be much difference, if any at all, between a finding
by a judge that he or she is not satisfied that a breach did not affect the result and
a finding that the result was in fact affected. He correctly surmised that there are
only two possibilities: either the result is affected or it is not. If a court is not
satisfied that the result is not affected, then it seems that the court would be saying
that the result is affected.
[175]
What, however, is the true principle in Considine, and its rationale? Why is it
necessary and how is it to be applied?
[176]
In my view, the principle is a necessary proposition under section 32(4) to cover
circumstances such as those which arose in Considine and kindred cases.
[177]
In Considine, it was declared that candidate John Cornforth received 945 votes in
elections and that he was duly elected and returned.
The petitioner, John
Considine received 938 votes. Cornforth therefore had a majority of 7 votes.
78
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents