registered voters in each constituency small, and in small communities people
know each other, since the petitioners were only able to produce a small, finite
number of persons who say they did not vote due to the late start, it should be
assumed that there are not many other persons who were disenfranchised
because of the late start. Learned counsel urged us to conclude that the trial
judge did not have sufficient evidence on which to set aside the return of any of
the appellants because the petitioners provided nothing approaching a
preponderance of evidence to prove that the results in the contested
constituencies were affected by breaches of election law. Mr. Martineau insisted
that the court could not have found, on a proper construction of the evidence, that
fewer than 502, 106 and 506 persons were prevented from voting in the St.
George, St. John’s rural North and St. John’s Rural West constituencies,
respectively, because of breaches of election law.
[188]
In my view, while these are attractive submissions, petitioners cannot be expected
to produce scores or hundreds of witnesses to give evidence in these cases. It is
noteworthy that Mr. Guthrie pointed out that in Hackney, Grove J described the
persons who were affected by the breach as a large number of persons who were
either prevented from voting or whom it might reasonably be supposed were
prevented from voting. Mr. Guthrie said that it is notable that it was not necessary
for any of them to be called to give evidence.
Approach
[189]
In my view, the trial judge made various findings of fact which fell within the
generous ambit of her discretion. These are contained in paragraphs 241-245 of
her judgment, in the Jonas/Quinn case; in paragraphs 397 and 398 in the
Fernandez/Maginley case and in paragraphs 276 and 278 in the Simon/Spencer
case. She correctly concluded, for example, that the evidence does not indicate
that only the persons who testified were unable to vote. I make the observation
that the witnesses for the respondents cannot speak for all of the registered voters
84
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents