in each contested constituency who for one reason or another did not vote. The
casting of votes at an election depends upon a variety of factors and it is not
possible for anyone to determine how many or what proportion of votes will go to
one or the other of the candidates.
[190]
The trial judge was correct in finding that the number of persons who did not vote
in each contested constituency was indeterminable. This was the critical factor in
her resolution of the issue whether the late opening affected the results in the
contested constituencies.
[191]
I think, however, that the learned trial judge erred, when, apparently, mainly
because the number of persons who did not vote was indeterminable, she
dismissed the available statistical information on the ground that she had “…
viewed the mathematical tests that were relied upon and found them very
unhelpful”. She did so without attempting to assess the available statistical
information disclosed by the evidence.123 An assessment of that information was
a necessary exercise, in my view, to a determination whether the breach may well
have affected the result in each contested constituency, before voiding a return
because the number of persons who did not vote was indeterminable.
[192]
The available statistical data reveals the pattern of polling at the various polling
stations. Such data can often reasonably provide a relatively clear picture as to
whether or not each winning candidate obtained a fortuitous lead which was
capable of being reduced had the polls opened early. The general pattern of the
poll in each contested constituency is that all registered voters do not usually vote.
Even if we were to add to the votes polled for each candidate a number
representing the votes of the registered persons who did not vote, it is obvious that
all of the persons registered to vote in each constituency would not have voted.
This immediately reduces the number of the registered electors who did not vote,
123
At paragraph 241 of the judgment.
85
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents