difference to the result, Mr. Jonas would have had to receive 502 more votes than
Mrs. Quinn-Leandro in order to equal the her assumed votes. He would have had
to receive 714 of the 926 votes, to 212 for Mrs. Quinn-Leandro. In other words, he
would have had to receive 77% of the 926 votes to Mrs. Quinn-Leandro’s 23% in
order to say that the election was affected because of the late start.
[196]
Mr. Mendes compared the statistics for the 2009 elections with those for the 2004
elections. He submitted that if the turnout in this constituency was destined to be
the same as in 2004 and this turnout was not achieved because of the late start,
585 registered voters would have been disenfranchised. He stated that for this to
have affected the result Mr. Jonas would have had to receive 502 more votes than
Mrs. Quinn-Leandro, in order to equal or overhaul the margin of victory. In other
words he would have had to have polled 546 of the 585 votes to Mrs. QuinnLeandro’s 39. This means that he would have had to receive the votes of 93.3%
of those assumed disenfranchised electors. He noted, however, that only 4
persons gave evidence that they turned up to vote but the polls were not yet open
and they left and did not return to vote. He accepted that one of them, Shenshaba
Henry, did not vote because of the late start. He noted that the other 3 witnesses
gave conflicting reasons for not returning to vote. He suggested that the evidence
in the case established that there was sufficient time for these other 3 persons to
have returned later in the day.
[197]
Mr. Mendes noted that a number of other persons left the lines before the polls
opened late, but the witnesses did not quantify the number of persons who left the
lines. He pointed out that there was no evidence that the number of persons who
left the lines equalled or exceeded the margin of victory of 502. He noted that the
evidence shows that some of those who left the line returned later to vote, but
there is no evidence that any of the persons who left the line did not return later to
vote. He also noted that the trial judge found that there was evidence that some of
the persons who left the line did not return later to vote. He insisted that there is
no evidence that the number of persons who did not vote because of the late start
87
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents