than the average. Mr. Maginley received 1,462 of the votes cast. Mr. Fernandez,
received 1,356 votes. The margin of Mr. Maginley’s victory was 106 votes. There
was no late voting in this constituency.
[205]
Assuming that voter turnout would have been 100% but for the late opening of the
polls, 750 registered electors would have been disenfranchised. For the late
opening to have affected the result, Mr. Fernandez would have had to receive 106
more votes than Mr. Maginley to equal the margin of victory. In other words, he
would have had to receive 428 or 57% of the 750 votes as against 322 or 43% for
Mr. Maginley.
[206]
Mr. Mendes asked the court to note that one person gave evidence that he turned
up to vote in this constituency but the polls were not yet open. He left and did not
return to vote. Mr. Mendes said that this witness however gave conflicting reasons
for not returning to vote. In any event, said Mr. Mendes, the evidence established
that there was sufficient time for him to return later in the day to vote. Mr. Mendes
noted that a number of other persons left the lines before the polls opened. He
pointed out that the witness, Simon, stated that between 40 and 50 persons left
the lines. Mr. Mendes noted that no evidence was given that the number of
persons who left the lines equalled or exceeded the 106 margin of victory. The
trial judge found that there was evidence that some of the persons who left the line
did not return later to vote. However, said Mr. Mendes, there was no evidence
that the number of persons who did not vote because of the late start either
equalled or exceeded the 106 margin of victory. He therefore insisted that the
petitioner, Mr. Fernandez did not prove his case so as to satisfy the trial judge that
the result was affected by breach of electoral law.
[207]
For my part, I note that in 2009 there were 3 polling locations in the St. John’s
Rural North constituency. Votes were cast as follows in the polling stations in
91
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents