[209]
A survey of the foregoing statistical information shows that Mr. Maginley obtained
majorities in 5 polling stations and Mr. Fernandez in 4. In York Centre polling
location, Mr. Maginley received an aggregate of 308 while Mr. Fernandez received
313, a majority of 5 votes. In the Cedar Grove polling location, Mr. Maginley
received 631 votes while Mr. Fernandez received 647, a majority of 16 votes. In
the Wesleyan polling location, Mr. Maginley received 523 votes while Mr.
Fernandez received 396, a majority of 127 votes for Mr. Maginley. This voting
distribution shows that it is unlikely or improbable that Mr. Fernandez would have
received the 428 or 57% of the 750 assumed additional votes if all of the
registered electors voted in the 2009 elections, in order to equal Mr. Maginley’s
assumed votes. That would have been about 9% higher than the 47.97% of the
votes which Mr. Fernandez received and higher than his majorities in the York
Centre and Cedar Grove polling locations. The court could not therefore have
been satisfied that breach may have affected the result or that it did not appear
that the breach did not affect the result.
Assessment on 91.10% base
[210]
The highest voter turnout in this constituency occurred in the 2004 elections when
91.10% of the registered electors voted. From this base, the assumed number of
voters who were disenfranchised by the late opening of the polls would have been
432. This figure is 91.10% of the 3,577 actual number of electors registered to
vote in 2009, which is 3,259, from which the actual votes cast in the constituency
in 2009 (2,827) is subtracted.
[211]
Given that the margin of victory was 106 votes, Mr. Fernandez would have had to
receive 106 more of the 432 votes than Mr. Maginley in order to equate his
majority.
He would have needed 269 or about 62.3% of the assumed
disenfranchised votes to 163 or 38.7% for Mr. Maginley. This is unlikely, given
that Mr. Fernandez only received 47.97% of the lawful votes actually cast in the
93
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents