election in the constituency.
[212]
It follows that Mr. Fernandez would not have proved his case that the result of the
election in the St. John’s Rural North constituency was or was likely to have been
affected by the breach to have satisfied the judge that it did not appear that the
breach did not affect the result. In the premises, I would allow Mr. Maginley’s
appeal and affirm the orders which the judge made on Mr. Fernandez’ petition in
her judgment of 31st March 2010.
St Johns Rural West – Simon/Spencer petition
[213]
The statistics show that there were 4,996 registered voters in this constituency.
The number of persons who voted was 4021. There were 9 rejected ballots. The
number of registered voters who did not vote was 975 or about 19.52%. This
meant that 80.48% of the electorate voted as opposed to 89.48% in the previous
General Election held in 2004; a difference of 9%. The turnout in 2004 was the
highest ever in this constituency. The national average percentage turnout in
2009 was 81.02%. The percentage turnout in this constituency was .54% lower
than average.
The appellant, Mr. Spencer, received 2,259 votes and the
opposition candidate, Ms. Gail Christian, received 1,753 votes. The margin of the
appellant’s victory was 506 votes.
Assessment on 100% base
[214]
Assuming that there would have been 100% voter turnout, but for the late opening
of the polls, 975 registered voters would have been disenfranchised. For the late
opening to have affected the result, Ms. Christian would have had to receive 506
more votes than Spencer from among the 975 who did not vote in order to equal
the margin of declared victory. She would have had to receive 739 or 76% of
those votes as against 233 for Mr. Spencer.
94
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents