opening of the polls.
Assessment on 89.48% base
[219]
The highest voter turnout in this constituency occurred in the 2004 elections when
89.48% of the registered electors voted. From this base, the assumed number of
voters who were disenfranchised by the late opening of the polls was 450. The
margin of victory was 506 votes. It is clear that even if all of the assumed
disenfranchised voters voted for Ms. Christian, she would not have obtained the
506 votes to overtake Mr. Spencer. This was very highly improbable. Mr. Simon
therefore did not prove his case to satisfy the trial judge that the result of the
election in the St. John’s Rural West constituency was affected by the breach so
that it did not appear that the breach did not affect the result. In the premises, the
learned judge erred when she invalidated the election of Mr. Spencer. I would
therefore allow Mr. Spencer’s appeal and set aside the orders which the judge
made in her judgment of 31st March 2010 on Mr. Simon’s petition.
Costs
[220]
The trial judge ordered each party in the High Court proceedings to bear their own
costs. The appellants, Mrs. Quinn-Leandro, Mr. Maginley and Mr. Spencer do not
specifically appeal the judge’s ruling on costs. Their appeals do not challenge the
costs order. Rather, their appeals each pray for costs in the appeals. They state,
under “Order sought”: “That the decision of Madam Justice Blenman be set aside
and that the Respondent’s petition be dismissed with costs.” The respondents do
not appear to have specifically challenged the judge’s costs order in the High
Court proceedings either. The order for which each respondent prays states: “(i)
That the appeal be dismissed with costs; and (ii) That the decision of the Hon
Madam Justice Blenman be confirmed, for the reasons which she gave, and for
the additional reason that the election in the constituency was not conducted in
substantial accordance with election law”. Accordingly, I do not propose to disturb
97
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents