Supervisor of Election and the Electoral Officials in relation to the conduct
of elections. The petitions all raised several matters of national
significance and indeed of public interest.
[419] Of great significance is the fact that the presentation of these
petitions and their defence have resulted in the Court, it is hoped, giving
much needed guidance as to whether it is legally permissible to use the
“Photo Lists”. The Court digresses to indicate that it had been used in the
previous General Elections with apparent no objection. It therefore
behoves the Court to make it clear that the use of the Photo Lists is not in
accordance with the Representation of People Act.
[420] Further, I am not of the view that any of the losing parties acting
unreasonably in either defending or presenting the petition, as the case
may be. Neither has there been any egregiously unfounded allegations
on the part of either the Petitioners and the Respondents.
[421] The Court hopes that the Supervisor of Elections and the other
election officials and the general public would be guided by this decision
insofar that it holds that the legislatively sanctioned Register for Elections
should be used in future elections. Whether a photo of the elector is to be
included in such a list is a matter for others to decide.
[422] The petitions have also served to enable this Court to provide
guidelines to the electoral officers in relation to the conduct of elections.
[423] Given the number of witnesses who testified in these petitions, the
Court is of the view that Learned Counsel did extremely well and
efficiently prosecuted and defended the petitions, in the allotted period of
two weeks. The written submissions, very extensive as they were, proved
extremely helpful to the Court.
[424] Relatedly, the Court hopes that all electoral officers, will take the
necessary steps in the future to ensure that the people of this State are
allowed to exercise their franchise in an electoral process befitting this
great democracy.
[425]Against this background, I am of the considered view that the Court
should order in these petitions, that each party bears its own costs. This
seems - based on the totality of the circumstances – what the justice of
the case warrants. Accordingly, the Court so orders.”
[222]
In my view similar reasoning is applicable in these appeal proceedings. While I
state no opinion as to fault because that issue was not squarely before this court
or canvassed before us, it seems clear that the circumstances, which gave rise to
these cases, were not in the creation of any of the parties who prosecuted these
appeals and counter-appeals. In my view, neither the High Court proceedings nor
the pursuit of appeals or counter-appeals came out of vexatious conduct,
unfounded allegations or unfounded objections on the part any of the parties.
99
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents