ŽDANOKA v. LATVIA JUDGMENT
5
3. The events of January and March 1991
20. On the evening of 12 January 1991 the Soviet army launched
military operations against the neighbouring country of Lithuania, whose
government had been formed in the same way as the Latvian government.
Soviet troops entered the television tower of Vilnius and the headquarters of
Lithuanian public television, and also tried to take the seats of the
Lithuanian parliament and other authorities. Massive crowds, made up of
Lithuanian citizens, came to the rescue of the institutions of the newly
independent Lithuania. Thirteen Lithuanian civilians were killed and
hundreds injured during the clash with the Soviet army.
21. The parties disagree as to who was responsible for the deaths during
the events in Vilnius on 12-13 January 1991. According to the respondent
Government, the CPSU was directly responsible for those deaths, in that it
had full and effective control of the Soviet troops. The applicant contested
the Government’s version, stating that the Soviet army’s aggression against
the Lithuanian government and the Lithuanian people was not a proven fact;
in this connection, she submitted a copy of a Russian newspaper article
which alleged that it had been the Lithuanian independence supporters
themselves who fired into the crowd with the aim of discrediting the Soviet
army.
22. At the same time, an attempted coup was launched in Latvia. On
13 January 1991 the plenum of the CPL Central Committee called for the
resignation of the Latvian government, the dissolution of the Supreme
Council and the assumption of full powers by the Latvian Public Rescue
Committee (Vislatvijas Sabiedriskās glābšanas komiteja), set up on the
same date by several organisations including the CPL. On 15 January 1991
this committee announced that the Supreme Council and the government
were stripped of their respective powers and declared that it was assuming
full powers. After causing the loss of five civilian lives and injuries to
thirty-four persons during armed clashes in Riga, this attempted coup failed.
23. According to the respondent Government, it was absolutely clear
that the attempted coup in Latvia was launched by the CPL against the
background of the Vilnius events, in the hope that Soviet troops would also
invade Riga to support the pro-Soviet coup. The applicant submitted that, at
the material time, a series of public demonstrations had been held in Latvia
to protest against the rise in food prices introduced by the Latvian
government; those demonstrations were thus the main reason for the events
of January 1991. The applicant also emphasised that, in their respective
statements of 13 and 15 January 1991, the plenum of the CPL Central
Committee and the Latvian Public Rescue Committee had not only called
for and announced the removal of the Latvian authorities, but had also
stated that early elections would be held for the Supreme Council.
24. On 3 March 1991 a national plebiscite was held on Latvian territory.
Electors had to reply to a question worded as follows: “Do you support a