(b) Intimidation of voters: 18 U.S.C. § 594
Section 594 prohibits intimidating, threatening, or coercing
anyone, or attempting to do so, for the purpose of interfering with an
individual’s right to vote or not vote in any election held solely or in
part to elect a federal candidate. The statute does not apply to
primaries. Violations are one-year misdemeanors.
The operative words in Section 594 are “intimidates,”
“threatens,” and “coerces.” The scienter element requires proof that
the actor intended to force voters to act against their will by placing
them in fear of losing something of value. The feared loss might be
something tangible, such as money or economic benefits, or
intangible, such as liberty or safety.
Section 594 was enacted as part of the original 1939 Hatch
Act, which aimed at prohibiting the blatant economic coercion used
during the 1930s to force federal employees and recipients of federal
relief benefits to perform political work and to vote for and contribute to
the candidates supported by their supervisors. The congressional
debates on the Hatch Act show that Congress intended Section 594 to
apply when persons were placed in fear of losing something of value
for the purpose of extracting involuntary political activities. 84
C ONG. R EC. 9596-611 (1939). Although the impetus for the passage
of Section 594 was Congress’s concern over the use of threats of
economic loss to induce political activity, the statute also applies to
conduct which interferes, or attempts to interfere, with an individual’s
right to vote by placing him or her in fear of suffering other kinds of
tangible and intangible losses. It thus criminalizes conduct intended
to force prospective voters to vote against their preferences, or refrain
from voting, through activity reasonably calculated to instill some
form of fear. 27
The civil counterparts to Section 594, 52 U.S.C. §§ 10101(b) and 10307(b),
may also be used to combat non-violent voter intimidation. See, e.g., United States
v. North Carolina Republican Party, No. 91-161-Civ-5F (E.D.N.C., consent decree
27
52