Case: 20-50407
Document: 00515441096
Page: 24
Date Filed: 06/04/2020
No. 20-50407
Take one example. Even though a court must uphold the law if there is
any conceivable basis for it, see, e.g., Box v. Planned Parenthood of Ind. & Ky.,
Inc., 139 S. Ct. 1780, 1782 (2019) (per curiam), the district court instead tried
to divine Texas’s true intent. Shooting in the dark, the court guessed that
Texas wanted to “forc[e] . . . voters to visit polls in-person [sic] during a novel
global pandemic, thus jeopardizing their health” and to “fenc[e] out from the
franchise a sector of the population because of the way they [sic] may vote.”
This kind of drive-by speculation about the state’s covert motives is utterly
impermissible and finds no support in this record. 42 Instead of searching for a
conceivable basis for the rules, the court jerry-rigged some straw men and
proceeded to burn them.
The district court also forgot that the legislature can “take one step at a
time, addressing itself to the phase of the problem which seems most acute,”
Beach Commc’ns, 508 U.S. at 316, without worrying that a rogue district judge
might later accuse it of drawing lines unwisely. 43 Undeterred, the court reasoned that it is absurd for Texas to “fenc[e] out voters under the age of 65” from
a mail-in ballot because of frets about fraud “while allowing older voters to
u[se] mail ballots,” thereby risking the same “rampant fraud.”
The district judge should know that that is not how rational-basis review
See Nordlinger v. Hahn, 505 U.S. 1, 15 (1992) (holding that the legislature need not
“actually articulate at any time the purpose or rationale supporting its classification”); U.S.
R.R. Ret. Bd. v. Fritz, 449 U.S. 166, 179 (1980) (“It is, of course, constitutionally irrelevant
whether this reasoning in fact underlay the legislative decision[.]” (quotation marks omitted)). And as observed, supra, it is a grave and malicious accusation for a district judge to
make.
42
See Armour v. City of Indianapolis, 566 U.S. 673, 685 (2012) (“[T]he Constitution
does not require the [state] to draw the perfect line nor even to draw a line superior to some
other line it might have drawn. It requires only that the line actually drawn be a rational
line.”); Fritz, 449 U.S. at 179 (“Where, as here, there are plausible reasons for [the legislature’s] action, our inquiry is at an end. . . . This is particularly true where the legislature
must necessarily engage in a process of line-drawing.”); McDonald, 394 U.S. at 809.
43
24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents