Case: 20-50407
Document: 00515441096
Page: 27
Date Filed: 06/04/2020
No. 20-50407
reads Symm’s four words—“[t]he judgment is affirmed”—to stand for too much.
“A summary disposition affirms only the judgment of the court below, and no
more may be read into [it] than was essential to sustain that judgment.”
Anderson, 460 U.S. at 784 n.5. The affirmance prevents us “from coming to
opposite conclusions” only “on the precise issues presented and necessarily
decided.” Mandel v. Bradley, 432 U.S. 173, 176 (1977) (per curiam).
The only precise issue in Symm (as relevant here) was whether it violates
the Twenty-Sixth Amendment to mandate that a student meet heightened residency requirements as a condition for being registered to vote. See United
States v. Texas (“Symm”), 445 F. Supp. 1245, 1251 (S.D. Tex. 1978) (three-judge
court), aff’d sub nom. Symm v. United States, 439 U.S. 1105 (1979) (mem.).
The Symm district court 47 held that it so violated. Id. at 1261. But the court
nowhere stated that strict scrutiny applies anytime a voting-procedure rule—
no matter the context—makes an age distinction. Even if it had, such a broad
decree would not have been essential to the judgment. See Anderson, 460 U.S.
at 784 n.5. The state officials will therefore likely succeed in showing that
Symm does not require strict scrutiny for the Twenty-Sixth Amendment claim.
Instead, employing McDonald’s logic leads inescapably to the conclusion
that rational-basis review applies. If a state’s decision to give mail-in ballots
only to some voters does not normally implicate an equal-protection right to
vote, see McDonald, 394 U.S. at 807–08, then neither does it implicate “[t]he
right . . . to vote” of the Twenty-Sixth Amendment. There is no reason to treat
the latter differently. Indeed, McDonald’s logic applies neatly to the TwentySixth Amendment’s text—which was ratified two years after McDonald—
because the Amendment similarly focuses on whether the state has “denied or
47
The Supreme Court heard Symm on direct appeal from the district court.
27
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents