Case: 20-50407
Document: 00515441096
Page: 41
Date Filed: 06/04/2020
No. 20-50407
of the Constitution to allow only voters of a particular race to vote by mail. See
McDonald, 394 U.S. at 807 (offering vote-by-mail on the basis of race would
trigger “more exacting judicial scrutiny”).
Plaintiffs do not mention the Fifteenth Amendment here, however. Nor
do any of the amici. Moreover, the majority opinion correctly observes that the
Supreme Court has said little to date about the Twenty-Sixth Amendment, and
that the closest analogy available under current precedent is the McDonald
approach to the Fourteenth Amendment. That is surely right. I would simply
add that, even if one were to assume that Texas law violates the Twenty-Sixth
Amendment, the preliminary injunction is likely flawed for another reason.
The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that “there are ‘two remedial
alternatives’ . . . when a statute benefits one class . . . and excludes another
from the benefit.” Sessions v. Morales-Santana, 137 S. Ct. 1678, 1698 (2017).
The remedy must provide equal treatment, of course. But equal treatment can
be achieved either by “withdrawal of benefits from the favored class” or by
“extension of benefits to the excluded class.” Id. “How equality is accomplished
. . . is a matter on which the Constitution is silent.” Id. (quotations omitted).
So how do courts decide which remedy to order?
Do we “level up”
(everyone gets to vote by mail) or “level down” (no one gets to)? To decide,
courts must determine “what the legislature would have willed had it been
apprised of the constitutional infirmity.” Id. at 1699 (quotations omitted). We
look to “the legislature’s intent, as revealed by the statute at hand.” Id. If “the
discriminatory exception consists of favorable treatment for a discrete group,”
we “strik[e] the discriminatory exception” and “extend[] the general rule . . . to
cover the previously favored group.” Id.
These principles readily apply here. Under Texas law, in-person voting
is the rule, and mail-in voting is the exception. And that is consistent with the
41
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents