Case: 20-50407
Document: 00515441096
Page: 45
Date Filed: 06/04/2020
No. 20-50407
[COVID] immunity alone” does not qualify as a disability, it also stated that “a
voter can take into consideration aspects of his health and his health history
that are physical conditions in deciding whether, under the circumstances, to
apply to vote by mail because of disability.” Id. at *26. In denying mandamus,
the decision also explained that a voter need not “declare the nature of the
underlying disability” and that Texas law “place[s] in the hands of the voter
the determination of whether in-person voting will cause a likelihood of injury
due to a physical condition.” Id. at *28–29. The court further concluded that
county clerks and election administrators “do not have a ministerial duty,
reviewable by mandamus, to look beyond the application to vote by mail.” Id.
at *29.
These clarifications of Texas law may warrant the withdrawal of some
claims or perhaps the additions of others. At a minimum, In re Texas changes
the complexion of the federal litigation, especially the aspects of this case
focused on the statements of state, county, and party officials about mail-in
voting. For example, wouldn’t it now be accurate for county clerks or campaign
officials to tell voters that they get to determine “whether in-person voting will
cause a likelihood of injury due to a physical condition”? Id.
A stay is thus warranted because the district court should have waited
for the state supreme court ruling and should now evaluate the federal claims
against that definite interpretation of state law. Maybe its result will be the
same; maybe it won’t. But this important issue should be resolved based on a
full and accurate understanding of the relevant state law.
We should end this administrative stay decision with that threshold
procedural error. But despite recognizing that the district court should have
abstained, see Maj. Op. at 9 n.13, the majority goes on to address other
procedural issues and the merits. In doing so, it makes the same mistake the
45
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents