39
information seeker can then disclose in turn such
information to the whole world; and
(c) The defense of privacy cannot be lightly brushed aside; and
(d) The competing interest (i.e. privacy and public interest) can
possibly be weighed after undertaking hearing of all
interested parties.
The above interpretation of section 11 of the Indian Act given
by the Delhi High Court was again considered by a larger bench of the
Delhi High Court (Arvind Kejriwal vs. Central Public Information
Officer) on 30 September, 2011, wherein the Court after exhaustively
interpreting that section observed that- (Para 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14
and 15).
(a) The said section 11 has to be read along with the
exemptions which have been provided in section 8; and the
right of the citizens to access any information held or under
the control of any public authority, should be read in
harmony with the exclusions /exemptions in the Act; and
(b) The test which has to be applied in such conflicting interest
is the larger public interest.
The Supreme Court of India in R.K. Jain vs. Union of India
(decided on 16 April, 2013) agreed with the above two decisions,
while giving observations on the issue of disclosure of some
information of ACR, which are quoted below (para-13, 14, 15 and
16):
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents