d) International challenges
407. Electoral rights are human rights and several have been enshrined
in various international instruments (see chapter 2, section 2). Some
of these universal or regional instruments have agencies and procedures
for reinforcing, on the basis of subsidiarity and complementarity, means
for protecting and defending that which is established domestically. The
subsidiary nature of international challenges means that domestic means
and mechanisms must be exhausted first before recourse is had to a
universal or regional mechanism. In addition, the complementary nature
of such challenges emphasizes the fact that international mechanisms do
not replace but at best are additional to the means of protection provided
for domestically. The jurisdiction of international bodies in charge of
overseeing the implementation of electoral and human rights needs to be
specifically recognized by the state party to the corresponding international
instrument, treaty, covenant or convention.
408. The international means for bringing electoral challenges are those
legal instruments provided for in international treaties and conventions by
which those with the standing to do so may have recourse, on a subsidiary
and complementary basis, to the competent body (for example the European
Court of Human Rights or the Inter-American Court of Human Rights)
after exhausting the domestic remedies provided. This enables a complainant
to challenge an act or judgement that is alleged to violate either electoral rights
or a right enshrined in the relevant international instrument. In due course,
the international body with jurisdiction resolves the dispute. Its decision is
binding if the state party has recognized its jurisdiction.
409. It should also be possible for another international organization to issue
non-binding recommendations to a given state party to an international
instrument, so long as the state recognizes its jurisdiction. For example, the
United Nations Human Rights Council is made up of 47 member states,
elected directly and individually by the members of the General Assembly,
based on an equitable regional distribution. The Council addresses situations
in which human rights, including political and electoral rights, have been
violated (dealing in particular with grave and systematic violations), and
makes recommendations on the promotion and protection of human rights.
It maintains a system of special procedures and a complaints procedure and
presents an annual report to the General Assembly.
410. At the regional level, the European Court of Human Rights may receive
applications from any person, NGO or group of individuals claiming to be
the victim of a violation by a state party of the rights, including electoral
rights, set out in the 1950 European Convention for the Protection of Human
Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. If the Court finds that there has been a
142