OHIO STATE JOURNAL ON DISPUTE RESOLUTION
(Vol. 27:2 2012]
eye towards disaggregating post-election disputes to analyze when and
whether mediation might have been productively injected.
A. Early Attempt to Stop Counting ofBallots
In his engaging book on the 2008 Franken-Coleman recount, Jay Weiner
identifies several instances when the parties rushed to court. In one early
example, a few days before the statute-mandated manual recount, the
discovery of thirty-two uncounted absentee ballots in Minneapolis prompted
the Coleman team to file for a temporary restraining order to prevent these
ballots (and, reaching for the moon, any other ballots statewide not counted
on Election Day) from being counted.116
At a hastily called Saturday morning hearing the day after the Coleman
team filed its motion, Ramsey County Chief Judge Kathleen Geiran was
extremely hesitant to issue the order, citing concerns about jurisdiction.
Minnesota election procedure required election contests to be overseen by an
appointed three-judge panel. 117 After bipartisan bickering and accusations
leveled back and forth, the judge ultimately refused to enter a temporary
restraining order or, for that matter, as the Franken side demanded, award
$1,460 in attorney's fees. The motion denied, votes in the end were counted,
but not after what is described as a series of press moves calculated to
misinform.118 Instructive for these purposes, "[i]n this initial scuffle between
116 Weiner, supra note 62, at 28.
11 7 Judge Kathleen Gearin dismissed the matter because no party had yet filed an
election contest lawsuit. Such a lawsuit would be filed in the Ramsey District Court, and
would be subject to MINN. STAT. § 209.045 (2008). As prescribed by statute, the case
would then be determined in Ramsey County by a three-judge panel appointed by the
Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. See Order in re: Motion for a temporary injunction
and/or a temporary restraining order, Minnesota Judicial Branch, Nov. 8, 2008,
available
at
http://www.rnncourts.gov/default.aspx?page=NewsltemDisplay&item=43582&printFrien
dly=true.
11 8 Coleman's team called a press conference at which it expressed concerns about a
later debunked report that the absentee ballots had been riding around in an election
official's trunk, suggesting a real possibility of tampering. Weiner, supra note 62, at 29.
Despite the election official in question confirming that the story was untrue, the story
refused to die; (See David Brauer, Minnesota Election Director Speaks: "Ballots in My
Car"
Story
False,
MINNPOST.COM,
Nov.
12,
2008,
http://www.minnpost.com/davidbrauer/2008/ll/12/4565/minneapolis_election_director_s
peaks_ballots_in_my_car_story_false). See also Paul Schmeltzer, Fox, with Pawlenty's
Help, Continues Spreading Car-Ballot Fiction, THE MINNESOTA INDEPENDENT, Nov.l3,
354
HeinOnline -- 27 Ohio St. J. on Disp. Resol. 354 2012
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents