6
CHIAFALO v. WASHINGTON
THOMAS, J., concurring in judgment
Court construes Wash. Rev. Code §29A.56.340 (2016) as
“enforc[ing] a pledge.” See ante, at 10; see also ante, at 1–
2, 7–9, 17. But §29A.56.340 did not involve the enforcement
of a pledge or relate to the appointment process at all.1 It
simply regulated electors’ votes, unconnected to the appointment process.
To understand the Court’s error, a brief summary of its
theory is necessary. According to the Court, Article II, §1,
grants States “the power to appoint” Presidential electors
“in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct.”
Ante, at 9. That “power to appoint an elector,” the Court
states, “includes power to condition his appointment.” Ibid.
The power to condition appointment in turn allows the
State to insist that an “elector pledge to cast his Electoral
College ballot for his party’s presidential nominee.” Ante,
at 9–10. And finally, “the State’s appointment power . . .
enables the enforcement of a pledge.” Ante, at 10. The
Court’s theory is entirely premised on the State exercising
a power to appoint.
Assuming the Court has correctly interpreted Article II,
§1, there are certain circumstances in which this theory
could stand. Some States expressly require electors to
pledge to vote for a party nominee as a condition of appointment and then impose a penalty if electors violate that
pledge. For example, under Oklahoma law, “[e]very party
nominee for Presidential Elector shall subscribe to an oath,
stating that said nominee, if elected, will cast a ballot for
the persons nominated for the offices of President and Vice
President by the nominee’s party.” Okla. Stat., Tit. 26, §10–
102 (2019). Oklahoma then penalizes the violation of that
oath: “Any Presidential Elector who violates his oath as a
Presidential Elector shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and,
——————
1 In 2019, Washington revised its laws addressing Presidential electors, eliminating the provision imposing a civil penalty on faithless electors. See 2019 Wash. Sess. Laws pp. 755–758.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents