7/8/2020
Mexico 9768, 9780 and 9828
59.
As to the absence of pressure on Chilean voters during the 1988 plebiscite, the
Commission points out in the abovementioned Annual Report, “the existence of a wide range of
resources employed by the government, whose effect is to cast a favorable light on its policies
among citizens. Some of these resources, consist in legal norms and others are practices
indulged in because of lack of controls to present these government actions.” (page 308)
60.
In this regard the Commission points out three types of situations: the
intimidation campaign as a result of official statements on the effects of a triumph of the
opposition, the activities carried out by mayors and the threats and actions against opposition
leaders originating from unidentified groups which have been occasionally linked to security
forces (page 308).
61.
In its Report on the Human Rights Situation in Panama in 1989, the
Commission stated regarding the electoral process that lead to the elections of May 7, 1989:
The general conditions in which the process was taking place … were slanted in favor of
the ruling party coalition and against the opposition because of the lack of freedom of
expression, the serious restrictions on the opposition’s right to personal liberty, the
grave violations of the right of assembly and the intimidation of members of the
opposition and pressures exerted against voters to support the ruling party candidates,
both by high-ranking government officials and by officers of the Defense Forces. (Page
52)
ii.
Organization of the voting process
62.
Another aspect linked to the authenticity of elections is the organization of
electoral process and the actual casting of voters. With regard to this subject there have also
been numerous statements by the Inter-American Commission in connection with specific
situations analyzed in its annual or special reports. Some extracts are included in order to refer
to their main features.
63.
Therefore, in the 1978 Report on the Situation of Human Rights in El Salvador,
after analyzing the exercise of political rights, the Commission reaches the following conclusion:
There is a generalized skepticism on the part of citizens with regard to the right to vote
and participation in government. In particular, opposition political parties go as far as
doubting the possibility of having pure and free elections, but also with respect to the
structure of the electoral system and the obstacles which parties face to organize in the
interior of the country. Because of all this, the Commission is of the opinion that
electoral rights are not effective in the present circumstances.
64.
In view of the aforementioned, the Commission recommends to the Government
of El Salvador in that Report to “Reform the electoral system, especially reorganizing the
Central Council on Elections with the aim of achieving an equitable representation of political
parties in it so that confidence in the system is restored.” (page 153)
65.
In the Seventh Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Cuba, in 1983, the
Commission deems that one of the elements that determines the limited political participation
of the population in important matters is the result of electoral mechanisms and control
exercised over it by the Government and the Cuban Communist Party. After analyzing the
principal characteristics of the Cuban electoral system, it points out as a “counterproductive”
element the preponderance of that political party, whose leaders intervene “in a decisive
manner in the operation of mechanisms to selects candidates to occupy free elective offices”
(pages 44, 45, and 48).
66.
The Commission also refers to the legal and institutional system entrusted with
the organization of elections in the Special Report on Paraguay in 1987, when, referring to
elections in that country, it analyzes the effect of proportional representation current when its
measures were applied to the Electoral Statute (Law 886/81). According to said measures, two
thirds of the members of electoral boards are members of the government party, when these
cidh.org/annualrep/89.90eng/Mexico9768.htm
11/17