limiting their ability to get accurate information. The next paper in this series will cover COVID-19
implications for democratic inclusion.
Domestic Influence Operations
Domestic and foreign actors are becoming increasingly adept at using disinformation, hate speech
and propaganda to exploit existing societal fears and fissures to further their anti-democratic aims.
They may accomplish these aims by creating content that reflects their narrative, or by amplifying false
narratives already in circulation.
For domestic political actors, the incentives to perpetuate false or misleading information about
COVID-19 may be linked to political calculations – either wanting to look prepared, exaggerating the
level of effort being put into public health measures around elections or misunderstanding the scope
or nature of the crisis. A Brazilian fact-checking agency, for example, has identified multiple messages
that advance a partisan narrative about the positive contributions of prominent government supporters
in the fight against COVID-19, including messages that make false health claims.26 In some instances,
state propaganda uses disinformation about government success battling COVID-19 to bolster the
strength and legitimacy of the regime in power. In Egypt, for example, state propaganda spread a
narrative that COVID-19 was a Western plot that was thwarted by Egyptian intelligence services and
that an Egyptian-developed cure was being shared with China and Italy.27
Political actors may also calculate that they can solidify power or drive up turnout for their party or
candidate by using disinformation to downplay the crisis or expedite elections before the economic
hardships stemming from the pandemic undermine their popularity. For example, the ruling party in
Poland was forced to change track after insisting until days before the presidential election scheduled
for May 10, 2020, that it would proceed. With a desire to hold elections as early as possible, the ruling
party initially downplayed the public health risks and then attempted to hastily adopt countrywide
mail-in balloting before finally postponing the election. Additionally, some analysts posit that Brazilian
President Jair Bolsonaro is carrying out a concerted disinformation campaign to dissociate himself
from the economic impact of COVID-19.28
Political calculations that lead domestic actors to create or perpetuate inaccurate narratives about the
public health situation and electoral preparedness for the sake of perceived political advantage is a
tension that will continue to play out as election dates approach. In all cases, there is a careful balance to
be struck between the importance of elections on the one hand and legitimate public health concerns
on the other. Decisions should be structured and consultative, rather than being made in an ad hoc
and politically motivated manner.
Political actors looking to deflect blame or play to the worst impulses of their majoritarian bases may also
deliberately deploy a mix of hate speech and disinformation to heighten interethnic or intercommunity
tensions. In India, a gathering at an Islamic event center in mid-March was blamed for the spread of
COVID-19, even as other religious congregations also failed to cancel large gatherings or implement
other safety measures during that time period. As the number of cases attributed to the gathering
increased, the hashtag #CoronaJihad began trending on social media along with messages blaming the
entire Muslim community for the spread of the virus. The hashtag appeared nearly 300,000 times and
was potentially seen by more than 300 million people.29 This polarizing rhetoric, which was amplified
by traditional media, has further entrenched the prejudice against an already-beleaguered minority
community.30 As a human rights activist conveyed to the authors, “we are being attacked by two viruses;
COVID will eventually be cured. But the more dangerous one is the communal virus. It will take a much
longer time to be vanquished.” Hate speech could easily lead to intercommunal tensions and create
-8-
International Foundation for Electoral Systems