CHAPTERS IN THIS BOOK
CHAPTER TWO
Linet Sithole, Brian Dube, and Cowen Dziva in
Chapter Two tackle the subject of the involvement
of traditional leaders in electoral processes in
Zimbabwe. In Zimbabwe, as is the case in many
countries in Southern and some parts of West Africa,
traditional leaders hold a special place in society, as
opinion leaders and in some as wielders of political
power. As a result, although in Zimbabwe they are
traditionally and legally prohibited from engaging
in partisan politics, they get involved in elections.
The chapter demonstrates that partisan conduct
of traditional leaders during electoral process
contravenes national law and has been a source of
electoral disputes in Zimbabwe. This notwithstanding,
the authors demonstrate that there remains a
dearth of legal studies with a nuanced analysis of
cases regarding this conduct. It is based on this
that the authors use court cases, extant literature,
and election reports to explore the legally expected
role and conduct of traditional leaders vis-a-vis their
practices during electoral processes. The authors
argue that the Constitution and relevant legislation
clearly and unambiguously define the role of the
institution of traditional leadership in electoral
processes. It is demonstrated that despite being rigid
in their application of procedural rules, Zimbabwean
courts have made some key judgments against the
partisan conduct of traditional leaders. The challenge,
though, is with traditional leaders who defy court
orders and continue to be prejudiced by politicians.
The chapter argues for relaxation of court rules and
procedures, respect and enforcement of judgments
to reign in errant leaders.
CHAPTER THREE
Wafula Wakoko in Chapter Three uses Kenya
to discuss the subject of pre-election dispute
resolution. It is argued that resolution of preelection disputes is among the bridges towards
a free and fair election and that it offers an initial
avenue for aggrieved parties to seek redress.
Kenya’s law bestows the jurisdiction for settling
pre-election disputes on the Independent Electoral
and Boundaries Commission, among other bodies.
The chapter explores how the EDR framework
is central to electoral integrity under the Kenyan
framework. Examined is the sufficiency of laws and
structure of political party politics. Also discussed
is the subject of dispute resolution in the context
of the following issues: the operational setting,
Electoral Code of Conduct, nomination rules, Party
primaries, allocation of special seats by use of Party
lists, independent candidates, and registration of
candidates for elections. It is noted that EDR alone
cannot solve the problem of violence in elections.
Compliance with existing laws, continued capacity
building of EMBs and courts, timely review of laws,
demilitarisation of elections, and voter education are
just but some of the factors that must be given life.
CHAPTER FOUR
Dzikamai Bere in Chapter Four discusses the
law and practice during the pre-election period.
Dzikamai opines that elections in most African
countries are a nightmare, usually associated with
violence and fraud, and are a breeding ground for
conflict that will take decades to resolve. Based
on this, the author sets out to discuss some of
the issues that could arise during the pre-election
period and their impact. In doing this, the author
analyses jurisprudence and best practices in the
pre-election period and the election environment.
The chapter looks at the role of the courts in EDR,
as well as the question of political violence and
its impact on participation. This is followed by
an analysis of the rationale of such frameworks
and any supporting mechanisms, using mainly
Zimbabwean and South African cases. In this,
the chapter also maps best practices and their
impact on elections. The chapter analyses the
link between the pre-election environment and
election outcomes. It discusses the infrastructure
for promotion of a credible election, which includes
peaceful dispute resolution. Particular attention is
given to the judiciary and the role of information in
activating participation, especially of marginalised
groups in Africa. The chapter concludes by making
a set of recommendations aimed at bridging the
gaps in law and practice in relation to the creation
of a conducive pre-election environment.
5