EVALUATION OF EFFECTIVENESS
OF EDR MECHANISMS
Viewed in totality, the pre-election dispute
resolution mechanisms in Kenya are increasingly
playing a significant and more prominent role
in electoral outcomes and overall electoral
democracy. This is illustrated by the increased
number of disputes adjudicated by these bodies,
which in effect ultimately affect electoral results.
In the 2017 elections, there was a prioritization of
electoral disputes, including by pre-election dispute
resolution bodies which resolved the ensuing
disputes within a period of three weeks. The timely
resolution of disputes, the perception of fairness
and impartiality by litigants, and the collaboration
with the judiciary through the Judiciary Committee
on Elections and Judicial Training Institute
contributed to enhanced effectiveness of these
EDR mechanisms.
THE PRE-ELECTION DISPUTE
RESOLUTION MECHANISMS
IN KENYA ARE INCREASINGLY
PLAYING A SIGNIFICANT
AND MORE PROMINENT
ROLE IN ELECTORAL
OUTCOMES AND OVERALL
ELECTORAL DEMOCRACY.
THIS IS ILLUSTRATED BY
THE INCREASED NUMBER OF
DISPUTES ADJUDICATED BY
THESE BODIES, WHICH IN
EFFECT ULTIMATELY AFFECT
ELECTORAL RESULTS
74
75
76
77
The above successes notwithstanding, these
various mechanisms have faced challenges,
as highlighted by various stakeholders. For
instance, there have been complaints about the
limited accessibility to the IEBC Electoral Code
of Conduct Enforcement Committee, which
provides enforcement partly owing to costs and
its centralised nature.74 It has been stated that the
Committee lacks clear procedures and issued
inconsistent rulings and penalties. The Peace
Committees provided for in the law have not
been operationalized and have no sanctioning
powers, thereby reducing their effectiveness.75
With respect to the IEBC as a body, there still
remains a trust deficit among a section of the
public thereby making it imperative to enhance
sustained consultations as well as transparency
and accountability.76
At a more general level, some of the limitations
of pre-election dispute resolution mechanisms
raised by stakeholders include centralisation with
the bodies predominantly within Nairobi and the
use of courtrooms ,which have an intimidating
presence; strict timelines for resolving pre-election
disputes, especially because the events leading up
to such disputes take place too close to elections;
administrative, resource, and capacity constraints
of the various bodies, including the limited number
of members of the tribunals that have to serve the
whole country as well as budgetary constraints;
perceptions of bias among some members of the
various pre-election dispute resolution bodies;
and a lack of effective remedies capable of being
granted by these bodies vis-à-vis the courts.77
EU EOM (n 59 above) 18.
As above.
As above.
L Thuo, Compendium of 2017 ELECTION PETITIONS: Select Decisions Issues and Themes Arising from the 2017 Elections in Kenya (ICJ Kenya: Nairobi, 2019) 10-12.
79
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents