In fact, the position taken by the Electoral Court
has legal basis in the form of Section 173 of the
Electoral Act. This provision empowers and, in a
way, enjoins the Electoral Court to report cases
of corrupt or illegal practices that arise in election
petition proceedings. If on reasonable grounds,
the court believes that such corrupt and illegal
practices prevailed in an election, its registrar shall
transmit a report to the Prosecutor General “with a
view to the institution of any prosecution proper.”29
It appears, though, that the question of whether
election petition proceedings are civil or criminal
has been partly addressed in Uganda in the case
of Besigye v Museveni & Anor.30 In this case, the
Court of Appeal stated that “[a]n election petition is
not a criminal proceeding,” inviting the conclusion
that it is a civil proceeding.31 The Court went
further to demonstrate its conclusion by referring
to a provision in the law that precludes it from
convicting a person of a criminal offence in the
course of determining a petition.32
In Malawi, election petition proceedings challenging
the result of the presidential election went to full
trial for the first time in that country’s history. In
Chilima & Another v Mutharika and Another,33
petitioners and respondents agreed to lay before
the High Court the question that is the subject
of this paper: “What is the standard of proof in
the determination of electoral petitions filed
under Section 100 of the PPEA [Presidential and
Parliamentary Elections Act]?”34 Although this issue
is later addressed in detail below, it suffices for
now to state that the Malawian Constitutional Court
re-affirmed the almost universal characterisation of
election proceedings and referred to them as “… a
special breed of claims which are governed by the
CPR, 2017.”35 The Court went on to state that this
has a bearing on the burden of proof.
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
The preliminary conclusions that we can draw from
this abridged survey of emerging jurisprudence in
the region is that characterising election petition
proceedings as sui generis is an approach that
resonates in Sub-Saharan Africa. Although different
language is used, it comes to the same conclusion,
that election petitions are a unique type of litigation.
Several jurisdictions have taken this approach,
namely, that election petitions are neither civil nor
criminal. In that regard, states are on the verge of
reaching harmony of law or approach. Secondly,
the prevalent position is that election petitions
proceedings are civil in nature, even though they
are not initiated in the same way as other civil claims.
This position was cemented by legislation from some
African sub-regions expressly divesting courts of the
competence to pronounce the guilt or otherwise of a
person while adjudicating on an election petition.36
RULES GOVERNING CIVIL
CLAIMS ARE APPLICABLE
MUTATIS MUTANDIS
(SUBJECT TO NECESSARY
CHANGES OR ADAPTATIONS)
TO ELECTION PETITION
PROCEEDINGS
Third, rules governing civil claims are applicable
mutatis mutandis (subject to necessary changes
or adaptations) to election petition proceedings.
The Nigerian Evidence Act is a case in point.37 In
no jurisdiction is evidence available to support the
application of rules governing criminal procedure as
applicable to election petition proceedings. Subtle
as it may appear, such detail assists in rooting a
case in civil proceedings. Now, it is timely to advance
the discussion to consider the burden of proof.
Section 173(a) of the Zimbabwean Electoral Act, as amended in 2018.
Besigye v Museveni & Anor (Election Petition No.1 of 2001) [2001] UGSC 4 (6 July 2001).
As above 13.
See section 59 (7) of the Ugandan Presidential Elections Act, 2005. See similarly worded provision in section 61(7) of the Ugandan Parliamentary Elections Act, 2005 divesting the
court of competence to pronounce on the guilt of a person when adjudicating on an election petition.
Constitutional Reference No.1 of 2019.
Chilima Judgment p.51.
As above.
As above 27.
The Evidence Act, Cap. E14 but now repealed by the Evidence Act, 2011.
89
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents