IFES Ukraine
The election campaign was largely peaceful and competitive, and candidates were generally able to
campaign freely without undue restrictions, according to the IEOM. However, the campaign was
marred by instances of negative campaigning and abuse of state resources, as well as cases of votebuying and involvement of public institutions and officials in the election campaign. Police need to
take further action to ensure that those who committed criminal and administrative offenses
related to election campaigning are effectively prosecuted and do not enjoy impunity. State bodies
should issue clear instructions to public officials and other employees setting standards for their
behavior during the election to prevent the abuse of administrative resources and public office.
The Presidential Election Law provides only a vague definition of what is considered election
campaigning and fails to draw a clear line between the campaign activities of the incumbent and
activities related to the exercise of his/her official duties as president during the campaign.
Poroshenko utilized this legal flaw effectively by de facto using his office for campaigning purposes
(i.e. during the so-called Tomos tour and similar events). The lack of clear legal definitions of what is
considered campaign activities has repeatedly been criticized by ODIHR. The Presidential Election Law
should provide clear guidance on what should be considered informational coverage of the election,
election campaigning, and official activities of public office holders who run as candidates.
In the 2019 election, most prospective candidates began their election campaign before their official
registration as candidates by the CEC. They also placed political advertising during the campaign
silence period including on election day and afterwards, prior to the calling of the second round. The
Presidential Election Law should introduce effective measures to deter prospective presidential
candidates from starting their campaigning early or in violation of campaign silence provisions. Such
measures could include introducing a formal registration procedure that obliges prospective
candidates to register as presidential nominees, combined with a prohibition to place political
advertising prior to their registration as prospective candidates as well as effective, proportionate,
and dissuasive sanctions for failure to comply.
Media coverage of the campaign was far from balanced. During the first round, media coverage mainly
focused on seven candidates, according to the IEOM. Debates, talk shows, and current affairs
programs were mainly used by candidates to discredit their opponents rather than to present the
program for their presidency. Certain TV channels gave most of their coverage to only one candidate.
Unmarked promotional materials on media, also known as “jeansa” or “hidden political advertising,”
were widely used during this election. The reasons for the unbalanced media coverage of the
campaign are rooted in the concentration of media ownership in the hands of a few oligarchs, lack of
proper state oversight over media campaign coverage, as well as a lack of proportionate, effective and
dissuasive sanctions for media violations and low journalistic standards. The Rada should consider
strengthening the independence and expanding the mandate of the National Broadcasting Council
to become an effective media oversight body. The Rada should also consider providing for the
establishment of an independent media council in charge of providing recommendations and
guidance to the media as to how to cover campaign events, and establishing effective,
proportionate and dissuasive sanctions for violations. The Presidential Election Law should be
amended to provide for a clear definition of “hidden political advertising.”
The Presidential Election Law provides for mandatory debates in the second round between the two
presidential candidates. These debates should be organized by a public service broadcaster on the last
Friday before the runoff election day during prime time. All expenses related to such debates are
16
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents