2019 Presidential Election: Post-Election Report
covered by the state budget. If one of the candidates refuses to participate in the debates, all airtime
is given to the other candidate. Holding such debates does not exclude the possibility other debates
between the candidates provided that the expenses for such debates are covered from the
candidates’ election funds. Poroshenko and Zelenskyi held a debate organized and agreed on by both
candidates’ campaign teams at Olimpiyskyi stadium in Kyiv on Friday April 19, but Zelenskyi declined
to participate in the official debate organized by the public service broadcaster later the same day;
hence, the full airtime was allocated to Poroshenko. Holding mandatory debates on the evening
before the day of campaign silence does not allow voters the time to properly analyze the respective
candidates’ platforms and statements, or to comment on their positions. This reduces the ability of
the public to make an informed choice. The Presidential Election Law should be changed to require
that the state-funded debates before the second round are held at least three to four days before
the election to allow the voters to make an informed choice. to comment on their positions. This
reduces the ability of the public to make an informed choice
Campaign finance
In 2015, the Rada adopted the Political Finance Reform Law that introduced a number of amendments
to the existing legislation governing political and campaign finance in Ukraine. While the new law
increased the transparency of political and campaign finance, remaining shortcomings identified by
the Group of States Against Corruption (GRECO), ODIHR, and the Venice Commission (such as lack of
regulation of “third-party” funding, lack of restrictions on excessive funding of campaigns and other)
limited its effectiveness in regulating the role of money in election campaigns.
Both domestic and international EOMs concluded that funding of the presidential election campaign
was not transparent: supporters of the candidates donated offices, paid for fuel and printed campaign
materials with funds being declared as third-party donations or donations-in-kind by the respective
candidates; some candidates did not pay for their YouTube campaigns, organized free concerts not
labeled as campaign events and/or allegedly made unofficial payments to members of election
commissions, observers and media.
The Presidential Election Law, as amended by the Political Finance Reform Law, provides that
candidates and the parties which nominated them can transfer money to campaign accounts without
any limits in terms of amount and number of transactions, contrary to Venice Commission
recommendations whereby a party’s/candidate’s own donations should not exceed a certain value.
Consideration should be given by the Rada to impose restrictions on the value of permissible
donations transferred not only by private donors but also by candidates themselves or by the
parties that nominated the candidates.
There are no spending limits in presidential elections. The absence of spending limits creates an
incentive for candidates to increase their campaign expenditures from one election to another. Both
the Venice Commission and ODIHR have repeatedly recommended setting a ceiling on campaign
expenses to prevent excessive use of funds and create a level playing field. Failure to address this
recommendation has led political parties and candidates to become increasingly dependent on
wealthy donors, which poses a risk of political corruption. Research from UNDP and others indicate
that increased spending and contributions by wealthy donors can have an adverse impact on the
representation of women in elected office; the more campaigning costs, the fewer women have the
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents