IFES Ukraine
resources to compete on a level playing field with men. The Rada should consider the possibility of
either introducing campaign spending limits or imposing restrictions on costly types of campaigning,
such as TV and/or radio advertising during an election.
In contrast to the 2014 presidential election, the amended Presidential Election Law required that
candidates in the 2019 presidential election had to submit not only post-election campaign finance
reports but also pre-election financial reports. These reports must specify all information on donors,
donations, and expenses and must be fully published (except for personal data) on the websites of
the CEC and National Agency for Prevention of Corruption (NAPC). Preliminary reports must be
published before election day. Before the first round, all 44 presidential candidates (including the five
that had withdrawn) filed their pre-election reports to the CEC and NAPC in a timely manner. As
required by law, Volodymyr Zelenskyi and Petro Poroshenko filed an additional pre-election report
before the second round vote. Given that there is no requirement in the legal framework that
candidates must file a post-election report after the first round, the second-round report covers only
the limited period from April 7 to 13. However, it is common that the majority of campaign expenses
are made in the last days of the campaign, which are not covered by any interim financial report. Thus,
voters do not have access to any information about the spending of the second round candidates in
the last days of the first-round campaign, the period from March 19 to 29. Although the candidates’
campaigns possess information about income and expenditure during this period, they are not under
a legal obligation to disclose it: this period is covered in the final report that is submitted and published
only after the election. This limits the effectiveness of the pre-election finance reports. The
Presidential Election Law should provide for filing post-election financial reports not only after the
second round but also after the first round. The reporting period covered by the financial reports
should be as extensive as possible, including covering income and expenses on the last day of the
first round campaign.
Third party donations, i.e. donations made in support of a particular candidate by a third party (often
without the consent of or informing the recipient), as well as donations in-kind are not properly
regulated by the laws. NAPC should approve the procedure regulating donations in-kind and clarify
how they are reported on by the parties and candidates in election.
Both the pre- and post-election financial reports must be analyzed by the campaign finance oversight
bodies, the CEC and the NAPC, which are obliged to publish the result of this analysis on their websites.
The IEOM concluded from the published reports that both campaign finance oversight bodies refrain
from accepting a mandate to determine any circumvention of transparency rules, including the misuse
of state resources, and also noted that the bodies lack investigatory powers. Their analyses of financial
reports were mainly technical in accordance with the established procedures. They found that the
reports of 17 first round candidates revealed signs of campaign finance violations such as accepting
donations from persons with tax debts or providing incomplete financial information. The fact that
the CEC and NAPC combined their efforts to evaluate campaign finance reports is a welcome
development. However, NAPC and CEC should improve the quality of analysis of the financial reports
with an increased focus on major violations, such as shadow financing and unreported expenses,
that could undermine the fairness of the election. The election laws should also clearly delineate
the oversight mandates of the CEC and NAPC to avoid duplication of efforts and ensure effective
campaign finance oversight. In the mid-term, the Rada should take steps to strengthen the
independence, accountability and resources of the NAPC whose role as political finance regulator
remains insufficient.
18
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents