IFES Ukraine
accordance with international standards. The isolated instances of electoral violations did not become
a critical obstacle for citizens in exercising their voting rights.
The secrecy of vote became an issue during second-round voting as the ballots were small and voters
did not fold them before casting them into the transparent ballot boxes; it was easy for observers and
election commissioners (as well as other voters) to see how a particular voter voted. To ensure the
secrecy of vote during the next election, the Presidential Election Law should either provide for using
translucent ballot boxes or require the CEC to issue instructions that require ballot issuing officers
to pre-fold the ballot paper and voters to fold the marked ballots before leaving the booth to ensure
the secrecy of the vote. The introduction of these measures should be accompanied by a
comprehensive information campaign prior to election day.
All election laws envisage a procedure
whereby voters who spoil a ballot paper is
entitled to a replacement. In practice, this
procedure does not apply to voters who vote
at their place of stay (homebound voters):
the election laws provide that the number of
ballots that are issued to the PEC members
who perform homebound voting must be
equal to the number of voters on the excerpt
from the voter list used for homebound
voting. The election laws should be
A senior citizen votes in the second round of the presidential
amended to entitle PEC members who
election at a polling station in Kyiv.
perform homebound voting to bring a
reasonable surplus of ballot papers to cater for homebound voters who accidentally spoil their
ballot and need a replacement. The number of ballot papers that accompany the mobile ballot box
must be strictly accounted for (their number announced and entered into the PEC journal prior to the
departure of the mobile ballot box).
As in previous elections, some polling stations were overcrowded on election day, especially during
the first round. The Presidential Election Law should require PECs to identify PEC commissioner(s)
who would be in charge of maintaining order and managing a queue at the polling station.
The Presidential Election Law tolerates a certain level of fraud by stating that the precinct results can
be invalidated only if the number of documented cases of fraud (ballot stuffing, illegal issuance of a
ballot to the voter, etc.) exceeds 5 percent. Such a threshold was repeatedly criticized by the Venice
Commission and ODIHR as inconsistent with international standards and best practices. The
Presidential Election Law should be amended to state that the result of the vote in a precinct can
be invalidated if the violation affects the election outcome in a precinct at a level whereby the
genuine will of the voters cannot be reliably determined. The criteria for invalidating the vote in the
precinct should be listed in the law.
Isolated cases of ballot stuffing were noted in both rounds of the election. In all cases, the stuffed
ballots were intercepted and invalidated, thereby not affecting the outcome of the vote in the
precinct. PECs, however, faced difficulties in deciding how to record the intercepted ballots – as invalid
ballots or as ballots that are not to be taken into account. The Presidential Election Law should specify
22
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents