Previous 40 / 61 Next

iii. Election administrators have stated that BIPA causes extra, unnecessary paperwork, additional printing expenses, and more election staff time. County election administrators and their staff have had to deal with agitated voters as a result of BIPA. Moore Dep. Tr. 53:4-16. iv. No funding was provided to counties or the Secretary of State to implement or provide education outreach regarding BIPA. 09/10/20 Trial Tr. (Corson) at 481:15-17; Moore Dep. Tr. 53:4-16. v. The fiscal statement for this ballot measure indicated it would have zero fiscal impact. Pl. Ex. 18/Stip. Ex.25;09110120 Trial Tr. (Corson) at 479:13-18. o. No Rational Basis. i. Defendant Mangan, Scott Cook, Katie Beall and some county elections administrators, including Dulcie Bear Don't Walk and Rina Moore, agree that BIPA is unnecessary. Mangan Dep. Tr. 167:4-8,10, 14-15 (BIPA is "a solution in search ofa problem."); Cook Dep. Tr.74:4-7 ("So, in my personal opinion, BIPA is, yeah, trying to solve a problem of voter fraud without presenting evidence that the problem even exists."); Beall Dep. Tr. 132:13-17 ("1 don't feel that there was any data, besides anecdotal stories, that showed that voter fraud was happening and thus [that] BIPA was a solution to a problem."). ii. BIPA makes it harder for people to vote and is more likely to harm rural and Native Voters. Pi. Ex.'s 23lStip. Ex. 4;24lStip. Ex. 6; 26lStip. Ex. 8; 113/Stip. 8x.2. 40

Select target paragraph3

● ● ●

Western Native Voice v. Stapleton

Judgment

Question Presented: Whether the Ballot Interference Prevention Act violates the Plaintiff’s right to vote, right to free speech, right to association, and due process.

Alleged Acts: Montana presents unique challenges as the fourth largest state in terms of land size, but the third least densely populated. Consequently, most voters utilize the absentee voting procedure. Montana also is home to seven Reservations, intersecting with sixteen different counties. These Reservations each have unique challenges to voting including a lack of home mail delivery, transportation that does not run on a regular route, taking administrative leave to drive in groups to polling stations, limited mail routes and drop-off locations, lack of convenient P.O. boxes, and mail delays. Further, many Native American Reservations have difficulties traveling due to high poverty levels, lack of working vehicles, car insurance, licenses to drive off of reservations, or money for gasoline to travel to polling stations. Some Native Americans on Montana Reservations have voted through the collection and conveyance of their ballot to local election offices by community members and third parties.

Summary: The Defendants failed to provide evidence that the state of Montana has or ever had a problem with unsolicited ballot collection or ballot interference. Thus, because the Ballot Prevention Act interferes with fundamental rights it is required to meet strict scrutiny. The Ballot Interference Prevention Acts limits the number of ballots per collector to six ballots and the court determined that this did not meet a compelling state interests, lack basis, and the voter were uninformed of this limitation at the time of voting — ultimately failing a strict scrutiny test.

Conclusion: The court found in favor of the Plaintiffs stating that the Ballot Interference Prevention Action violated the right to free speech, right to vote, right to association, and right to due process.

Legal Issue(s)

Elections as a Fundamental Right
Indigenous Persons
Vote Verification and Transmission

Applicable Law(s): Ballot Inference Prevention Act

Region: Americas

Country: United States of America

Language of Decision

English

Court: Trial Court

Election Type: Review of law

Date of decision: Sep 25, 2020

Geolocation

Latitude: 46.55684320353664

Longitude: -112.0529752389978

: Geolocation

Primary Documents

Western Native Voice v. Stapleton.pdf
English
Download View

Election Judgments - IFES

Select target paragraph3

Western Native Voice v. Stapleton

Primary Documents

Notifications