531US1
Unit: $$U9
[05-01-02 10:02:37] PAGES PGT: OPIN
Cite as: 531 U. S. 98 (2000)
121
Rehnquist, C. J., concurring
advantage of the safe harbor provided by 3 U. S. C. § 5.
Bush v. Palm Beach County Canvassing Bd., ante, at 78 (per
curiam). December 12, 2000, is the last date for a final determination of the Florida electors that will satisfy § 5. Yet
in the late afternoon of December 8th—four days before this
deadline—the Supreme Court of Florida ordered recounts of
tens of thousands of so-called “undervotes” spread through
64 of the State’s 67 counties. This was done in a search for
elusive—perhaps delusive—certainty as to the exact count
of 6 million votes. But no one claims that these ballots have
not previously been tabulated; they were initially read by
voting machines at the time of the election, and thereafter
reread by virtue of Florida’s automatic recount provision. No one claims there was any fraud in the election.
The Supreme Court of Florida ordered this additional recount under the provision of the Election Code giving
the circuit judge the authority to provide relief that is
“appropriate under such circumstances.” Fla. Stat. Ann.
§ 102.168(8) (Supp. 2001).
Surely when the Florida Legislature empowered the
courts of the State to grant “appropriate” relief, it must have
meant relief that would have become final by the cutoff date
of 3 U. S. C. § 5. In light of the inevitable legal challenges
and ensuing appeals to the Supreme Court of Florida and
petitions for certiorari to this Court, the entire recounting
process could not possibly be completed by that date.
Whereas the majority in the Supreme Court of Florida
stated its confidence that “the remaining undervotes in these
counties can be [counted] within the required time frame,”
772 So. 2d, at 1262, n. 22, it made no assertion that the seemingly inevitable appeals could be disposed of in that time.
Although the Florida Supreme Court has on occasion taken
over a year to resolve disputes over local elections, see, e. g.,
Beckstrom v. Volusia County Canvassing Bd., 707 So. 2d 720
(1998) (resolving contest of sheriff ’s race 16 months after the