There is nothing to suggest that they occasioned needless expenses to be
incurred. It seems clear to me that a just outcome on the issue of costs is that
each party should bear his or her own costs in these proceedings.
Summary
[223]
The learned trial judge erred when she held that the issue of late voting by
persons who voted after 6:00pm in polling stations in the St. George and the St.
John Rural West constituencies was properly pleaded. I would therefore allow the
grounds of the appeal by Mrs. Quinn-Leandro and Mr. Spencer, which challenge
that decision. Notwithstanding this, the trial judge did not err when she held, as a
matter of fact, that there was no late voting in the St. John Rural West
constituency by persons who joined there after 6:00pm on election day.
Accordingly, I would have dismissed the grounds in the respondents counternotices which seek to challenge this decision, had late voting been properly
pleaded. I would also have dismissed the grounds of the counter-notices which
seek to challenge the decision by the trial judge that late voting (after 6:00pm) on
election day in the contested constituencies did not breach Rule 1(7) of the
Election Rules, had late voting been properly pleaded.
[224]
The trial judge did not err when she held that voting after 6:00pm by persons who
were in line at 6:00pm did not breach Rule 1(7) of the Election Rules.
Accordingly, I would dismiss the grounds in the respondents’ counter-notices
which sought to challenge that decision.
[225]
The learned trial judge did not err when she held that the late opening of polling
stations (after 6:00am) on election day in the contested constituencies breached
Rule 1(7) of the Election Rules. I would therefore dismiss the grounds of the
appellants’ appeals, which challenged that decision of the trial judge.
[226]
The trial judge did not err when she held that notwithstanding that the late opening
100
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents