[65]
The foregoing statements suggest that it is necessary to review the manner in
which the trial judge arrived at her decision that there was no late voting by
electors who entered the lines after 6pm on election day. Basically, the judge
found that the evidence that persons entered the lines after 6:00pm to vote, in
particular the evidence of Mr. Pena and Mr. Gomez, was not credible. She further
stated that although Ms. Gail Christian was forthright with the court, much of her
evidence was hearsay and inadmissible.
The judge’s reasons for the finding of fact
[66]
The judge reasoned this aspect of the case in her judgment in this way:40
“[259] In relation to the closing of the poll and in view of the totality of the
credible evidence, the Court has no difficulty in concluding that the polls
were closed at some stations after 6:00 p.m. This was to facilitate persons
who were in the line at 6:00 p.m. to vote. In this regard, the Court has paid
particular regard here again to the press release that was issued by Ms.
Lorna Simon, the Supervisor of Elections. It bears noting, however, that
the Court is unable to accept the evidence of Mr. Pena and Mr. Gomez
when they said that persons entered the lines after 6:00 p.m. The main
reason for the Court so concluding is that both of these witnesses who
testified on behalf of the Petitioner, in relation to this aspect of the case,
were less than credible.
[260] The Court pauses here to say that Mr. Ramon Gomez (Greenbay),
who testified on behalf of the Petitioner, was not as forthright as he could
have been during cross-examination. Indeed, he was not as generous
with the truth as he ought to have been. He was forced to resile from
some aspects of his evidence during intense cross-examination by both
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. Martineau and Learned Senior Counsel, Mr.
Mendes. While the Court accepts that persons voted after 6:00 p.m., he
was obviously pushing the numbers further up the continuum. To that
extent, therefore, the Court is of the view that he is not a very credible
witness; neither is his evidence reliable. The Court has no choice than to
attach very little weight, if any, to this aspect of his evidence, insofar as
the late voting is concerned.
[261] Similarly, Mr. Pena, who testified on behalf of the Petitioner, was not
very credible or reliable. Accordingly, the Court attaches very little weight
to his evidence. In contradistinction, the other witnesses who testified on
behalf of the Petitioner were candid, particularly, Mr. Lovelace Christopher
(Greenbay); Mr. Francisco Matthias (Greenbay); Ms. Harrigan (Five
40
At paragraphs 259-261.
31
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents