Islands) and Mr. Winston Joseph. It bears noting that even though Ms.
Christian was forthright with the Court, much of her evidence was hearsay
and inadmissible. The Court is therefore able to attach very little weight, if
any, to her evidence.”
Submissions
[67]
Learned counsel for respondent Simon submitted that the judge should have
found that some part of the late voting in John’s Rural West was done by persons
who joined the line after 6:00pm. This, he said, arises from the evidence that
persons so joined the lines, and given the extent to which late voting took place.
[68]
Mr. Guthrie and Mr. Astaphan referred to the evidence of witnesses on behalf of
the respondents, Gomez and Pena, who said that they saw “about 100 people”
entering the polling station between 6:00pm and 8:00pm through “a small gate on
Federation Road” and that some persons were still voting after 10:00pm.
Lovelace Christopher, who was a polling agent at Greenbay, said that he saw
people “trying to enter on Federation Road” at about 6:30pm. Bernadette Ephraim
stated that she saw persons voting at Greenbay after 8:00pm.
[69]
Mr. Guthrie and Mr. Astaphan submitted that although the judge disbelieved the
witnesses Gomez and Pena, the disputes which emerged in oral evidence should
make little impact on the overall position. Counsel argued that as a matter of
common sense, the length of time that voting continued after 6:00pm, was unlikely
to have only been the result of queues which formed before 6:00pm. Counsel
insisted that, on any calculation, a very large number of persons must have voted
after 6:00pm. Accordingly, counsel asserted that it was unlikely that all of these
voters were in line inside the main gate at 6.00pm. Counsel insisted that it was
rather more likely that a considerable number of voters entered through one or
other of the 2 gates in Federation Road as witnesses Pena and Gomez testified.
[70]
On the other hand, Mr. Martineau urged us to note the evidence filed on behalf of
32
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents