incorrect in law, when it continued by stating: “However, the law allows for anyone
who is in the line before 6:00 pm to cast their ballot” and “all persons who are in
line as aforesaid will be permitted to vote no matter how long it takes”.
[96]
Mr. Guthrie contended that even beyond this, as a matter of fact, only some voters
would have known about this press release and it is impossible to say how many.
He argued that voters who did not see or hear of the release would have
proceeded on the basis of the allotted voting period. It meant, for example, that if
they were unable to vote in the morning, they could not have been expected to
return at or after 6:00pm when they would have assumed that the polls were
closed. They would have been guided by the hours of voting provided in Rule
1(7).
[97]
Mr. Guthrie submitted, further, that in any event, time added at the end of the day
cannot substitute for time lost at the beginning of it. For this to be so, said
counsel, it would be necessary to show that every voter was made aware of the
time change. It would have been necessary to inform them that they could have
voted in the extra period. Counsel argued that it would also have been necessary
to allow voters to attend at any time during the extra period, not just at the outset,
with a specific closing time for the polls. Any other arrangement, said counsel,
would not have been a true or fair substitute for lost time. It would also have
affected and distorted the result of the election if late voting took place in some
areas, but not in others, because the electorate is not uniform in political affiliations
across a given constituency. Counsel contended that this means that the only fair
system requires one rule for all. Additionally, he said that because the law
precludes any investigation into how a person voted it is impossible to say that
what occurred did not affect the result of the elections in the contested
constituencies.
Counter-submissions on behalf of Quinn-Leandro
42
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents