provisions of any law in that behalf and no other person may be
registered.
(3) Every person who is registered as a voter in pursuance of
subsection (2) of this section in any constituency shall, unless he
is disqualified by any law from voting in that constituency in any
election of members of the House, be entitled so to vote in
accordance with the provisions of any law in that behalf.”
(Emphasis added by counsel for the appellants)
[109]
Mr. Mendes highlighted Russell. In that case this court interpreted the effect of an
identical provision (section 27) in the Constitution of St Vincent and the
Grenadines. Sir Vincent Floissac, CJ, stated as follows:62
“The constitutional right conferred by section 27 is two-fold. The
first is the basic right to be registered as a voter in the appropriate
constituency. That basic right is granted to every Commonwealth
citizen of the age of eighteen years or upwards, if he possesses
the prescribed qualifications relating to residence or domicile in St
Vincent and is not disqualified by Parliament from registration as
a voter. The second is the concomitant right to vote in the
appropriate constituency. That concomitant right is granted to
every citizen who is entitled to the basic right. That concomitant
right is a right to vote 'in accordance with the provisions of any law
in that behalf'. This means that although the manner of voting is
statutory or customary, the right to vote is inherently
constitutional.”
[110]
These provisions undoubtedly confer a constitutional right to vote. It is a right that
is contained in the constitution to be exercised “in accordance with the provisions
of any law in that behalf”. The reference is to electoral laws. With respect,
however, I do not agree with the submission by counsel for the respondents that
the right to vote is merely a statutory right created by Rule 1(7).
It is a
constitutional right which is to be exercised in accordance with electoral law,
including Rule 1(7). The critical question in the context of the present case,
however, is what impact does this have on legality or otherwise of persons who
were in line before 6:00pm voting after 6:00pm?
62
See page 139 of the judgment.
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents