between 6:00am and 6:00pm. It is conceivable that voters acting independently
and consulting their own individual convenience could turn up in droves an hour or
2 before the 6:00pm. It would be a strong position to take that persons who are
still in line at 6:00pm are, through no fault of their own, automatically deprived of
their right to vote simply because the lines were too long. This, Mr. Mendes
argued, would amount to a direct deprivation of the right to vote. It would also be
undemocratic and would not result in the election of persons truly representative of
the constituency. He relied on Sauve v Attorney General of Canada and Bruno
v The Election Appeal Board.
[115]
In Sauve, McLachlin CJ stated:68
“The right of all citizens to vote, regardless of virtue or mental
ability or other distinguishing features, underpins the legitimacy of
Canadian democracy and Parliament’s claim to power… More
broadly, denying citizens the right to vote runs counter to our
commitment to the inherent worth and dignity of every individual…
the vote of each and every citizen is a badge of dignity and of
personhood. Quite literally, it says that everybody counts.”
[116]
In Bruno, the Canadian Federal Court of Appeal, commenting upon the Appeal
Board’s argument that the law should be interpreted to mean that persons in line
at closing time were not entitled to vote, stated as follows:69
“…. The Board’s interpretation is in direct conflict with the obvious
purpose of the Election Law, which is to allow eligible Board
members to exercise their democratic right to vote for the
Councillors of their choice. The Board’s interpretation taken to its
ultimate logic, means that eligible voters who may have been
standing in line for hours would be unable to vote because the
line had not progressed fast enough and hence having been
unable to vote by 6 pm, would be prevented from voting. This
would, in my view, constitute an absurd result.”
[117]
Rule 1(7) is a provision that elaborates the manner in which the right to vote under
section 40 of the Constitution is to be exercised. To that extent the Rule has a
68
69
At paragraphs 34-35 of the judgment.
At paragraph 43 of the judgment.
50
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents