adopted by the trial judge that there was substantial compliance with electoral
laws, notwithstanding the breach of Rule 1(7) which she found, was correct.
[127]
The operative statutory provision is section 32(4) of the Representation of the
People Act, and in particular, that aspect of it which states, in effect, that no
election shall be declared invalid if it appears to the court that that the election was
conducted substantially in accordance with the law as to elections.
The basic principles
[128]
The decided cases show that an election court will not invalidate an election on the
ground that there was there was substantial non-compliance with electoral law if
the breach of elections procedure stipulated by law is trivial. There must be such
a substantial departure from elections procedure stipulated by law that would
cause an ordinary person to condemn the election as a sham or travesty. A
considerable departure is required. Accordingly, an election court would usually
only invalidate an election on this ground if the judge is really satisfied that the
breach is serious. The rationale is that the return of a member of the legislature by
the electorate should only be invalidated in a clear case where the court has
serious doubt that the election was a manifestation of the wishes of the electorate.
These principles are elaborated in many cases.
[129]
Accordingly, the Court of Common Pleas stated as follows in Woodward v
Sarsons:70
“…we are of opinion that the true statement is that an election is
to be declared void by the common law applicable to
parliamentary elections, if it was so conducted that the tribunal
which is asked to avoid it is satisfied, as matter of fact, either that
there was no real electing at all, or that the election was not really
conducted under the subsisting election laws. As to the first, the
tribunal should be so satisfied, i. e. that there was no real
electing by the constituency at all, if it were proved to its
70
[1875] L.R. 10 C.P. 733, at pages 743-744.
54
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents