satisfaction that the constituency had not in fact had a fair
and free opportunity of electing the candidate which the
majority might prefer. This would certainly be so, if a majority
of the electors were proved to have been prevented from
recording their votes effectively according to their own
preference, by general corruption or general intimidation, or by
being prevented from voting by want of the machinery necessary
for so voting, as, by polling stations being demolished, or not
opened, or by other of the means of voting according to law not
being supplied or supplied with such errors as to render the voting
by means of them void, or by fraudulent counting of votes or false
declaration of numbers by a returning officer, or by other such
acts or mishaps. And we think the same result should follow if, by
reason of any such or similar mishaps, the tribunal, without being
able to say that a majority had been prevented, should be
satisfied that there was reasonable ground to believe that a
majority of the electors may have been prevented from electing
the candidate they preferred. But, if the tribunal should only be
satisfied that certain of such mishaps had occurred, but should
not be satisfied either that a majority had been, or that there was
reasonable ground to believe that a majority might have been,
prevented from electing the candidate they preferred, then we
think that the existence of such mishaps would not entitle the
tribunal to declare the election void by the common law of
Parliament. (Emphasis provided by counsel)
[130]
In Re Parliamentary Election for Fermanagh and South Tyrone71 Carswell LCJ
stated as follows:
“The decided cases show that a fairly considerable departure from proper
procedure has been required before the court will set aside an election on
this ground: see Parker's Law and Conduct of Elections, paras 19.89 to
19.91. In particular, irregularities in respect of opening hours at a single
polling station have not been regarded as sufficient to avoid the election:
see Drogheda 2 O'M & H 201; Islington, 5 O'M & H 201; East Clare 4 O'M
& H 162. We take into account also the remark of Willes J retailed by
Martin B in Warrington 1 O'M & H 42 at 44, that a judge to upset an
election ought to be satisfied beyond all doubt that the election was void,
and that the return of a member is a serious matter and not lightly to be
set aside.”
He provided further enlightenment as to the test for substantial compliance when
71
[2001] NIQB 36 (19 October 2001).
55
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents